When to ask
Timing matters more than wording:
Set your workflow step to fire on the dedicated Review Request trigger with a Send Offset such as
+1d or +2d. The Review Request trigger fires on every publish, including unpaid publishes and republishes, so the offset gives the client time to read the report, share it with their agent and build a repair request while the experience is still fresh.
Report Published is not a good fit either. It fires only when the order is already paid at publish time (an unpaid publish fires Payment Pending instead), so clients who pay after the report is published would never get the ask. Every workflow step has a Send Offset, so timing is not the issue; coverage is.
Because Review Request also fires on a republish, a client whose report you republish will get the request again unless your workflow accounts for it.
What to say in the email
Short, warm, specific. The template that works best:- Thank them by name for choosing you
- Reference the property (specific, not generic) by address or by a one-line note (
"your new place on Oak Street") - Make the ask clear and small: “If you have 60 seconds, your Google review really helps our small business”
- One link (not three). Pick Google or Yelp, not both; the one you pick is the one most clients will use.
- Keep the voice personal. Workflow emails go out from your company name. There is no configurable reply-to on workflow emails, so don’t promise that replies land in your inbox; give a phone number or a contact email in the body if you want to hear back.
- “Please leave us a 5-star review” (coercive, violates Google’s and Yelp’s TOS)
- Multiple requests in one email (dilutes the ask)
- Generic property reference (
"your inspection") - Review-gating language (“If you had a great experience, leave a review; if not, email us”) which violates FTC rules and most review platform TOS
Pick Google or Yelp (not both)
Pick the one platform where you want to build your presence. Clients will almost always click only one link; splitting the attention halves your conversion.- Google — the right choice for 95%+ of firms. Local-search dominance, higher conversion, better defense against negative reviews.
- Yelp — the right choice if your market has a strong Yelp culture (urban coastal, hospitality-adjacent) or you already have a strong Yelp presence to maintain.
When a client leaves a negative review
- Respond publicly, calmly, within 24 hours. No excuses, no counter-attacks. Thank them, acknowledge, offer to make it right offline.
- Reach out privately if you can. Many 2 or 3-star reviews get upgraded when the client feels heard.
- Learn from it. Was the problem process (we missed something), expectation (they thought we did something we didn’t), or personal (bad day)? Adjust accordingly.
When a client leaves no review
- No follow-up requests. One ask is enough; nagging is counterproductive.
- Don’t take it personally. 20 to 30% response rate on review requests is excellent; 10 to 15% is typical.
Compliance notes
- Do not offer anything in exchange for a review (discount on next inspection, gift card, etc.). This violates FTC guidelines and Google’s TOS and can get your Google Business Profile suspended.
- Do not review-gate. Sending the review link only to clients you expect will leave 5-stars (“If you had a great experience, click here; otherwise email us”) violates the FTC’s testimonial guidelines.
- Do not use fake reviews. The usual temptation. The usual bad outcome.
Related
- Review requests (setup walk-through)
- Communication templates
- Communication workflows
- Variable tags reference (
$GoogleReviewLink,$YelpLink)